Author owns old violin, author does the test, author picks modern violin over $10 million ones, author tries to defend herself post facto (bad test, not tuned, blabla), then some audiobabble (sweet sound, personality, other nonsense).
I think the whole problem lies in the underlying assumption that older, more expensive violins sound ABSOLUTELY better. The author does not support this claim, and the study also demonstrated otherwise. The author, and apparently the study as well, both are in agreement that it is all about personal preference.
In fact, the author admits that she preferred some of the newer violins to the older ones and with that "audiobabble" she says they SOUNDED better. So when how can you blame her to "choose violins on price stick" and then also call her ignorant when she prefers some other violin "over the $10 million ones" ??
The author concludes that the reason older violins are so valuable isn't just because they have some magical qualities that make them sound better, or they are very obviously more amazing than newer ones, she says that older violins have this history attached to them. This imagined beauty to them because of the legends attached to them.
Oh and that "not-tuned" "older-strings" stuff was there to imply that an old violin, is an OLD violin. A newer violin will have an advantage due to the new parts, the new strings. But apparently nothing is absolute. A new violin isn't always better than an older one (hence her preference for her 200-yr-old one at home). Heck, she even said how she has heard different complains about newer and older violins. So how in the world was your take "i am an auidophool, i choose based on price stick" ?!?!? She EXPLAINED how things are completely independent of age or price.
pick best does not mean pick oldest, news articles said study was identification, study subject says study was preference, study says study was preference. How you could possible reach the grand parents takeaway is seriously concerning.
Her mid-1800s Italian has completely different characteristics from a 17th century Italian. A string player spends months or years trying many instruments before deciding on one. I've never known a professional musician who cares whether they're playing on a modern or an older instrument, they care whether they have the right instrument for them. You have no idea what you're talking about. Please just stop.
