> It guarantees that the logs are stamped externally, are committed to disk and that the logs haven't been tampered with by isolating them from other processes and user accounts that can modify or write to them. Don't need journaling on top, just separation of concerns.
What if you want to consolidate all your logs in a single place instead of scattered over many files? What if you want the logs to be shipped to a remote host without storing them locally?
If your answer is syslog: welcome back to the problem.
> Well what the hell does your NFS daemon do when your network goes down, your adapter gets hotplugged after a failure or someone falls over the cable? There is so little of the problem solved by systemd it's unbelievable. The RIGHT solution is to make the processes resilient to failure conditions like this.
That has got nothing to do with the init system. Just because the services themselves can recover from dependencies that temporarily go down, doesn't mean that I want to see tons of useless error messages during startup. I want my NFS daemon to start after the network is up, so that it doesn't bother me with useless "network is down" messages. Recoverability is a completely independent (though desirable) property.
Its not different as both can and must be solved by network daemons listening for network change events. So solving reliability solves the startup issue.
What if you want to consolidate all your logs in a single place instead of scattered over many files? What if you want the logs to be shipped to a remote host without storing them locally?
If your answer is syslog: welcome back to the problem.
> Well what the hell does your NFS daemon do when your network goes down, your adapter gets hotplugged after a failure or someone falls over the cable? There is so little of the problem solved by systemd it's unbelievable. The RIGHT solution is to make the processes resilient to failure conditions like this.
That has got nothing to do with the init system. Just because the services themselves can recover from dependencies that temporarily go down, doesn't mean that I want to see tons of useless error messages during startup. I want my NFS daemon to start after the network is up, so that it doesn't bother me with useless "network is down" messages. Recoverability is a completely independent (though desirable) property.