Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>> "Ads are a soft form of brainwashing"

Every input we receive to our brains could be said to be a soft form of brainwashing.

Good advertising serves a use for consumers. Without it, you wouldn't be aware of what you can buy/do etc. If you want to opt out of that, fine. Personally, I find it invaluable to be aware of what is going on.



No, a constructive argument showcasing pro's and cons and highlighting merits of competing products serves a use for consumers.

And while that also has a soft brainwashing effect, it actually adds some information that allows you to make a conscious decission. An ad is just the brainwashing.


Perhaps if you're particularly susceptible to brainwashing, then advertising could be a bad thing. But I think you have to give people a bit more credit than that. It's about giving potential consumers information so they can make informed choices.

Word of mouth is still the best form of advertising though - agreed. That's not to say other forms of advertising aren't effective, or useful for the consumer.

For example, I know what movies are out mainly through billboards. It's useful to me. If one looks interesting, I might look it up on the net and see if I want to go see it. I'm not being 'soft brainwashed', I'm being informed of a new movie I might want to go see.


It's about giving potential consumers information so they can make informed choices.

For a long time now advertisement has been about manipulating people's emotions so that they seek fulfillment in the product being advertised. When was the last time you saw an Apple ad where the purpose was listing the specs so the consumer can make an informed choice?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: