Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>The cornerstone of liberal democracy is...

For the love of god or anything you find holy, STOP insisting we live in a democracy!

I stop reading any article that asserts we live in a democracy or should strive to live in one.

We live in a republic. http://www.c4cg.org/republic.htm

[edit for auto-complete]



> We live in a republic

Republic refers to any form of government which is not a monarchy.

The US is a republic -- specifically, a federal republic -- it is also a democracy -- specifically a representative democracy.

The whole "The US is not a democracy, its a republic" thing makes as much as saying "16 isn't a perfect square, its an even number."


For the love of god or anything you find holy, STOP insisting that only direct democracy counts as democracy!


Even being succinct and saying "a representative democracy" doesn't imply a form of government which is constrained by a constitution.

Saying democracy instead of republic just undermines the common understanding of how our government was setup to function.


> Even being succinct and saying "a representative democracy" doesn't imply a form of government which is constrained by a constitution.

Neither does saying "republic". And "representative democracy" isn't succinct compared to "democracy", its verbose.

> Saying democracy instead of republic just undermines the common understanding of how our government was setup to function.

No more than saying "republic" instead of "democracy". A "federal republic that is also a representative democracy governed under a written constitution" would avoid that problem, but its a lot to write, when "democracy" is the part that is relevant to the point you are trying to make.


We live in a republic

A democratically elected representative republic, specifically. I agree that you are correct in a pedantic sense, but our society is a "democratic society" in a more general, looser sense. Given the context of TFA, I think the usage is correct enough.


We live in a republic, but is a republic not extremely similar to a representative democracy?


"Republic" is essentially orthogonal to "representative democracy".

The United States of America has a government which is both a republic (and, more specifically, a federal republic) and a representative democracy.

There are republics that aren't any kind of democracy, and representative democracies that are not republics (e.g., the United Kingdom.)


I thought about commenting on that, but I knew what he meant.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: