Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

a town square isn't just a place, it's always a polity that requires common values and a shared culture. Otherwise you at best have an airport lobby.

A town square in Cologne where 90% of participants don't hail from Cologne but London, Mumbai and San Francisco aren't going to solve the problems of Cologne or have any stake in doing so.

Which also reveals of course what Twitter actually is, an entropy machine designed to generate profit that in fact benefits from disorder, not a means of real world problem solving, the ostensible point of meaningful communication.



I think it's quite clear to anyone paying attention right now that sharing a polity does not mean sharing values and culture.


> A town square in Cologne where 90% of participants don't hail from Cologne but London, Mumbai and San Francisco aren't going to solve the problems of Cologne or have any stake in doing so.

Upholding at least some utterly basic foundational values of humanity doesn't require holding any stake.


And if you're not interested in upholding basic values? What if you're looking to intentionally destroy things instead?

Verified residency is better than nothing for putting real money on the table. Although if you've been to a local town meeting, you'll know it's still not perfect.


> utterly basic foundational values of humanity

Except human across the planet doesn't even agree on those "foundational values". What seems obvious and fundamental to us, often isn't to others.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: