Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

[flagged]


Just curious, what's your background in batteries? From my understanding, sodium based batteries are safer than lithium, but I would defer to anyone with real expertise in the subject.


Replace your Sodium Or Lithium by petrol or gas, and your comment would have been typical in the beginning of the 20 century.

We are all sitting on ‘minibombs’ since we developed cars and personal devices with batteries. That is the point of those objects, to carry an extremely dense storage of energy in order to operate. And indeed, that is the basic premise of a bomb, concentrate high amounts of energy in a small volume, but similarities stop there. Human development has made those devices extremely safe to use, fortunately.


Obligatory xkcd:

https://xkcd.com/651/


Na is the safest Alkali, they get increasingly bad as you go DOWN (not up) the perodic table. Learn basic facts before you spit BS


Na is the _next_ safest alkali metal after lithium :)


As you go down the table, the alkali metals (in metallic form) get far nastier.


There are plenty of laptops and phones in airplanes today.

What makes you think the risk will increase in the future?


Are sodium batteries more dangerous?


I don't believe they are. Sodium is less reactive than lithium.


Wait till you find out what internal combustion engines run on...


Vapor. Which is convenient for fire fighting in all sorts of ways. Just because you put the fire out does not mean you've discharged all the stored energy and re-ignitions are a serious concern in lithium battery systems, whereas with fuel, you actually can make the fuel inert and then you can remove it, separately from the vehicle.


> Look, I'm all for better battery technology

Go on.

> but we are also building a ton of mini bombs that we all hold in our pockets

Yea. That's the definition of "battery".

Clearly you are against batteries.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: