Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Honestly, the best picture quality I’ve ever seen was over 20 years ago using simple digital rabbit ears.

That I find super hard to believe!



Why? ATSC is 19Mbps. A single 1080i video using that whole bitrate will look quite good.


Many confounding factors. That’s just one dimension of image quality. Others include things like the panel quality, production quality.


that's 19mbps including error correction. only 10 after, and that's using mpeg2 which is probably roughly equivalent to 6-7mbps av1


"A terrestrial (over-the-air) transmission carries 19.39 megabits of data per second (a fluctuating bandwidth of about 18.3 Mbit/s left after overhead such as error correction, program guide, closed captioning, etc.),"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ATSC_standards#MPEG-2


But that's the whole multiplex, right?

It could be a single channel, but usually you have many in the multiplex. I don't know how it works in the US, but for DVB-T(2) that's how it is.


Circa 2009 when analog TV was first shut-off in the US, each DTV station usually only had one channel, or perhaps a second basic one like a static weather radar on-screen. Some did have 3 or 4 sub-channels early on, but it was uncommon.

Circa 2019, after the FCC "repack" / "incentive auction" (to free-up TV channels for cellular LTE use) it became very common for each RF channel to carry 4+ channels. But to be fair, many broadcasters did purchase new, improved MPEG-2 encoders at that time, which do perform better with a lower bit-rate, so quality didn't degrade by a lot.


Wow, that's really different compared to what we have in EU, with up to 10 SD channels in a single multiplex.


You could technically fit 10 SD channels together in the US, except I recall that the government ("FCC") specifically REQUIRED (at least during initial rollout) at least one to be in highdef, unless you applied for a special waiver.

These days the FCC is unlikely to care, but I suspect viewership would suffer if any of the major broadcast networks downgraded their "main channel" signal to SD.

This explains the typical arrangement, as well as listing some of the extreme cases:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_subchannel#United_Stat...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_subchannel#Tradeoffs




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: