yes. In fact, when they were first rolled out, it was difficult for me to cancel them for the customer. (this has been fixed; the recurring payments functionality is pretty good now. But it was crap when it came out.) but I have far more customers asking for some kind of recurring payments that /refuse/ the paypal recurring payments than customers that take the paypal recurring payments. Hell, I have more customers that have their bank send me a paper check every month than I have on paypal recurring payments.

The feedback I get is that if I offered recurring credit card payments, most of my customers would be using them; rather than the, say, one percent that uses paypal recurring payments and five percent that uses their bank to send me a check automatically.