Imagining that information exists in some pure unvarnished state (like a pristine mountain lake), until it is polluted by some bad actor (big bad logging company).
The metaphor doesn't work at all. It just more "the truth is under attack"
Exactly what I thought when reading this. And that's the moment I stop taking the (probably somewhat valid) claims seriously. This reminds me of the arguments against streaming we had a few years ago, that confused compression/decompression, completely disregarded local caching and calculated as if all network infrastructure in the world was just being used for streaming.
An iPhone can write a whole email in a few seconds using a local model.