Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I got an email from Bank of America yesterday about a problem setting up my account. I had set up a new account, and this email knew that, and knew the name of the company, etc. There were no links in the email, just a note to call the BofA business number. I verified the number on the BofA website -- it was the same number -- and I called them.

They couldn't tell me why I got the email, and what the problem was with my account. The representative couldn't see a record of this email set.

I'm 100% certain this email came from Bank Of America. There was nothing in the email that was phishing -- no links, no bad phone numbers.

The SPF, DKIM, and DMARC all passed googles's ARC-Authentication-Results. The DKIM key is 2048 bits long.

I asked Bank of America to investigate, and they said "it must have been a phishing message" and sent me a link on how to look out for phishing.

I'm pretty sure this was just a glitch; some system that does some consistancy check ran too early while the account was being set up and generated that email.

However, because they told me it was "phishing" I just sent a FedEx to the CTO with the complete paper trail advising them that EITHER their DKIM keys were compromised and they need to issue a public warning immediately OR their incompetent staff and IT system gave me the runaround and wasted an hour of my time. Either way, I want a complete investigation and resolution.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: