Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Is this a "guns don't kill" argument ?

Microsoft Word and Excel aren't generative tools. If Excel added a new headline feature to scan your financial sheets and auto-adjust the numbers to match what's expected when audited, you bet there would be backlash.

And regarding scrutiny, morphine is a immensely usefulness tool and it's use surely extremely monitored.

On the general point, our society values intent. Tools can just be tools when their primary purpose is in line with our values and they only behave according to the user's intent. AI will have to prove a lot to match both criteria.



> And regarding scrutiny, morphine is a immensely usefulness tool and it's use surely extremely monitored.

I went to high school in a fairly affluent area and I promise you this is not true. If you have money and know how to talk to your doctor, you can get whatever you want. No questions asked.

You can even get prescription methamphetamine - and Walgreens will stock generic for it!


Definitely not if you're a white male under 60 years old. They won't even give you opioids after surgery now because you are "high risk" .

If you're really rich it may be a different story, but any of the "middle class" good luck. And if you do find a doctor with some compassion, they are probably about to retire.


All I can say is that I am speaking from life experience. It sounds like our experiences have been different.


> If you have money and know how to talk to your doctor

That's a decently high bar I think ?

Imagine what you can do if you have money and know how to talk to your local police...


> If Excel added a new headline feature to scan your financial sheets and auto-adjust the numbers to match what's expected when audited

- Sounds like what my accountant already does.


Right, but accountants have qualifications and, more importantly, have to sign their name and accept liability for the accounts they're submitting. That's the part that's missing when "computer says ok".


Your accountant's cooking the books is handmade and a work of art, passed down by generations of accountants before them and they'll proudly stand in front of any auditor to claim their prowess at their craft.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: