Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Your version of the question has the qualifier "in local elections".

Yes, the point is that qualifier works because when you're talking about people voting "in the USA," you can be talking about local or federal elections. "In federal elections, how many people vote in local elections" makes no sense. "In the USA, how many people vote in local elections" makes sense, because voting in the USA can encompass both local and national elections.

I understand that there are many people who ignore local elections. But I disagree that talking about voting "in the USA" means that local elections should be excluded.

> In other words "in the USA elections" implicitly points

You're using quotations for something that wasn't said. The original comment was "in the USA, can illegal immigrants vote?"



> But I disagree that talking about voting "in the USA" means that local elections should be excluded.

I agree with you, however, whether you like it or not, that phrasing will default to the federal elections to most people and especially foreigners.


Especially given a few years of heated political discussions around the possibility or not of the practice, concerning precisely the federal level.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: