Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Maybe there's some negative American exceptionalism here (the idea that what works in other countries can't work in the US because reasons) but many other countries have no jaywalking laws or much more lax versions (e.g. only applies to motorways) and have much lower pedestrian deaths than the US. Road safety is a cultural thing and relates to how unequal a person's rights are based on their mode of transport.

Growing up in the UK, which is car-centric but not as much as the US, jaywalking was an alien term and concept. I remember being confused by the concept when I first visited the US. In the UK there be many crossing with or without lights and regular traffic islands for pedestrians. You get used to crossing the road without signal controlled crossing. And yet the vehicle death rate in the UK is 4 times lower per 100,000 population than the US, 2 times lower per distance driven and the pedestrian death rate is 5 times lower.



Agreed, growing up in Portugal, I had no idea about the concept. Cars even stop for you here outside of crosswalks. When I moved to London UK, I was surprised how wild things were there. Jaywalking is just part of the city.

But I love that way. I think the alternative is just fascism. The idea that pedestrians are illegal if they don’t use a crosswalk seems insane to me.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: