Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The issue with supplementing with gas is that you still need a gas furnace. And if you have a gas furnace, why spend $10k+ on a heat pump?


You shouldn't spend that much. If you need an air conditioning system, making it a bidirectional heat pump is negligible unless people are trying to rip you off. (They are)

Are you one of the grifters or just confused?


Comparing a cold-climate AC to a cold climate heat pump shows how confused YOU are.

ACs in cold climates are cheap. Cooling a house down 20 degrees doesnt take a lot of BTUs. Plus they’re just cheaper per-BTU and a typical northeast homeowner is going to be comfortable installing a cheap brand because it’s not life-or-death if your AC goes out.

When you start talking about having a heat pump being the primary heat source in a cold climate home, that’s a different ball game. First you need WAY more BTUs to heat a house in winter lows — even NYC hits single-digits most winters, that’s a 60 degree temperature differential. And you need to be prepared for the worst temperatures which basically necessitates a top-end brand like Mitsubishi which is rated down to historic-ish lows.

Not to mention that many homes don’t have central ducts, so converting to a heat pump means ductwork or mini splits..

All in all it’s not really a negligible thing.


No, the difference in cost between central air conditioning (a heat pump that works in one direction) and a heat pump that works in both directions is negligable unless you're being ripped off.


Just saying something doesn’t make it true.

Here’s a concrete example that took 5 minutes to find. Two condensers from the same company, same seller, same SEER, same series, same tonnage, except the second does heat. The heat pump is 29% more expensive.

2 Ton 14.3 SEER2 Trane Air Conditioner Condenser - RT Series. $1615

2 Ton 14.3 SEER2 Trane Heat Pump Condenser - RT Series. $2090

https://hvacdirect.com/trane-a4ac4024d1-2-ton-14-3-seer2-air...

https://hvacdirect.com/trane-a4hp4024d1-2-ton-14-3-seer2-hea...


That very quickly pays for itself.


Goalposts movin’ like crazy


Goalposts haven't moved. Refer to my first post and stop spreading FUD about heat pumps.


You’re spreading the FUD




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: