Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

and you'll be suing them for what exactly?


It will be done in arbitrage before anything like that. It is perfectly ok to sue a business for inappropriate actions that are not clearly stated or wrongfully done. After closely reviewing Github's policy and terms of service. They do not state they will change your username(with or without notice). Unless the account is "inactively held for future use." I highly doubt OP had been inactive enough to be considered a squatter. Either way, Github needs to update their policies describing why and how someone like OP had to have their username changed without notice. If this happened to me with a username that I carefully crafted and was unjustifiably acted on. I would certainly speak with support then sue them if there is no resolution, hoping to settle out of court because going through the court process is a giant pain for both parties.


they don't have to update their policies, it's their website and they can do what they want with it

unless you've paid them (which @usernamex doesn't seem to), then there's not even a contract with them

they will call your bluff, you'll go to court, then you'll lose and you'll have their legal fees to pay


If Github has the power to change usernames or account details without notice then I would like them to communicate that to me clearly and upfront. Also, you dont have to pay github to have legal grounds. If the account is used for business purposes(business card, or other forms), then github could cause you financial damages no matter how small. As a business, they should try to be more open and communicative with the users. OP clearly does not have much of a case, which makes that a lame example to bring up this court stuff. This is my bad, however if OP was using his account as we both mentioned then he would have a good case.

Overall, Github should update their policy to communicate more clearly with us. This is something we should demand from them. We can just throw up our hands and say github can do whatever they want. If that was the case and Github came out to say that, I would never do business with them or use their services/platform.


> If Github has the power to change usernames or account details without notice then I would like them to communicate that to me clearly and upfront.

you can want whatever you want, they have no contractual relationship with you and no obligation to consult you about anything.

> Also, you dont have to pay github to have legal grounds. If the account is used for business purposes(business card, or other forms), then github could cause you financial damages no matter how small.

if you haven't paid them there is no contract or any binding commitment or obligation for them to provide you with any service whatsoever

> This is something we should demand from them.

what are you going to demand with? you aren't their customer

> If that was the case and Github came out to say that, I would never do business with them or use their services/platform.

maybe don't build your business on companies you don't have a binding contract with?

see: Apollo, Tweetbot


Great examples of how letting these private companies act however they feel like will ultimately lead us down to a worse experience and quality of life. Apollo and Tweetbot were great software that made those platforms much more useable and brought a lot of dedicated users to the platform. Now we have is poorly made official apps that offer nothing to the users. I don't use either platforms. I don't have an account with them anymore. I removed myself from them. Yet people like you make them important and justify their decisions. Instead of listening to their userbases' feedback, they instead PR it up and wait till there is only dysfunctional idiots left. TickTock started out as that and everyone else is trying to copy that homework. There are too many people in this world with poor mental health.

We should realize that somehow there needs to be an increase in regulation in business behavior. Even to how businesses treat other businesses that use their online platforms. Internet is too much of a wild west. It just does not seem there is modern actions and behaviors at play here. too narrow minded and thinking of how they are free too whatever they like without consequences.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: