Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

"What even is a “known broken” technique — how do you establish that some technique “can’t work” rather than “just haven’t found a good execution” so far?"

If you insist on 100% certainty, nothing.

If you are satisfied with "millions upon millions of people have used this and it has been broadly revealed to be a dead end", then bowling certainly has a known-bad technique that is very appealing to people just picking up the ball for the first time.

But if you really, really want that 100% certainty, then by all means go forth and base your decisions about what to focus on on that.

If you set the bar at anything even remotely less than 100% certainty, though, you'll find there are known-bad techniques. Heck, there are techniques that aren't just known to not work, they are known to lead to injuries with high reliability; see the lifting world, for instance. There's a difference between being an iconoclast and refusing to learn from the experiences of others. From the outside they may look similar but they are not the same.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: