Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

There are things that I consider problematic in old movies, but what if someone is curious about what was that era like, given that we have outgrown some blatant prejudices?


If I want to know what an era was like, I don't necessarily start with fiction. I would look at primary sources.


I think that at least in regard to culture, works of fiction are likely to be a more effective tour guides of what an era was like than nonfiction accounts of that culture.


At any rate, regardless of which you use as your tour guide (or even both), your picture will necessarily be incomplete. Hell, the people who actually live through an era don't even have a complete picture. That's just the nature of life.


Fiction can tell you about what and how people were thinking.

The concept of primary source is orthogonal to fact/fiction.


The strangest thing about our society is that we have absolutely no problem with dramatizations of killing and murder in movies.

Even to the point of having an entire genre of "Horror" movies with a general theme of murder defining the genre.

We properly view those scenes though as complete fiction.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: