Same here. My impression is that the puzzle lovers turn out to be the algorithm geeks. You need a bunch of those, but I can't see how a room for of complexity analysis experts necessarily creates well-structured software.
I'm an API design geek. I've never seen a cool puzzle about API design, or something remotely related.
i'm pretty sure one of quora's questions is/was designing an api for something in python (probably time, given how bad the current api is).
also, replying more to the other post above - you can get insights from puzzles. a lot depends on the puzzle (which is why ita is getting praise here). for example, the ita puzzle i remember taught me a lot about handling data in large numbers of dimensions (in particular, it made me think about the "curse of dimensionality" which was something i was aware of before, but hadn't considered in detail; it also led me to understanding some tools for dealing with it - locality sensitive hashing being the most interesting at the time).
I'm an API design geek. I've never seen a cool puzzle about API design, or something remotely related.