Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I'm curious, why do you think the US benefits the most from this? I would think Ukraine.


escalation of the crises in Europe, which historically - see: WW2 - has massively benefited the US. more incentive to import American gas. damage Russia; the US objected to Nord Stream in the first place. also can be used as justification to increase support for what is essentially a proxy war in Ukraine

the EU/US economic stratosphere is not necessarily a zero-sum game, but in general if Europe’s economy separately takes a hit, the US gets stronger


Because the US LNG industry stands to benefit. https://peoplesworld.org/article/pipeline-ploy-how-u-s-natur...

Not to mention the US grand strategy of preventing Russian integration with Europe.


If we are speculating without any basis then why not Turkey?

They are now signing deals with Russia about transporting gas to Europe.

Obviously it was Turkey!

No, no, sorry - it was Qatar! They are signing gas deals with Germany now. They stand to profit from it.

Please, stop speculating without any basis. You can make a case for basically anyone who trades gas or had any issues with Russia.


Prevent negotiations between Russia and Germany particularly. Then sell exorbitantly priced US LNG to a captive Europe. All of which is basically happening now.


If we are speculating without any basis then why not Turkey or Qatar?

Please, stop speculating without any basis. You can make a case for basically anyone who trades gas or had any issues with Russia.


Almost all nearby players had motives.

Russia benefits if they can spin it as US action, as the damage to US alliance and trust relationships are huge and definitely strategic goals and gains for them. For a while in the beginning, when it wasn't clear that a functioning (but unused) pipeline remained, Russia was off the suspect list. But it turned out the sabotage missed a pipe and that fact keeps Russia high on the suspect list.

As for US, Germany had already given in to the US pressure and nixed the pipeline and made the gas deals. Why would US go and blow it up? It is possible, but makes little sense.

Whoever did this did so knowing that US will ultimately be blamed. Biden kinda set US up for that with veiled threats regarding NS before the Russian invasion. It's either Russia or UK/Ukraine, is my guess.


I'd expand:

Most Baltic basin states, except Germany sort of, benefit by reduced reliance of Europe on Russian gas. Russia is constantly making threats to all of it's neighbours in that region but keeps discord in Europe via the gas blackmail. Similar story for Ukraine.

Western Europe - it's also not inconceivable. For example France is a net exporter of energy to Germany, and probably also doesn't like the Russian gas blackmail (while being less susceptible to it herself).

So literally anyone has some kind of incentive. Except perhaps Germany. You could still argue that Germany benefits in the long run as that reliance is bad for them, as it turns out, but it's harder to see them going cold turkey on themselves.


Let's not forget about Turkey and Qatar! China is also reexporting Russian gas to Europe.

My bet is on India tough! /sarcasm

Please, stop speculating without any basis. You can make a case for basically anyone who trades gas or had any issues with Russia.


> Please, stop speculating without any basis. You can make a case for basically anyone who trades gas or had any issues with Russia.

...is my point. I'm not speculating, merely saying basically anyone could benefit, so that alone tells you nothing.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: