Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Humans may not be able to handle as much heat as scientists thought (sciencenews.org)
3 points by sohkamyung on July 28, 2022 | hide | past | favorite | 2 comments


Just read the article, what? 35° or even lower as the max. temperature humans can handle in the street?

In my entire life, just for living here I've usually estimated that humans can handsomely handle 40° to 50°.

Full 10-20 Celsius degrees above what the paper says. Well, it actually says that the upper limit of tolerance is below 35°.

Here we have people kindly walking in the street - maybe with a bottle of water in their hands - literally for hours at 45-50°, no thousand of deads for heat stroke or other issues.

Yes, heat is highly dangerous, you can move at 45-50° in the street, just like you can walk the streets at 0° to -10° for maybe a couple of hours with a t-shirt if you are sufficienty adapted to cold temperatures. But you need to have some precautions as well, and at some point to take some effective measures to control the external temperatures so it doesn't overheats you.

But, 40-50° at hight humidity (over 80%), are, in my personal experience and for what I've already saw in several decades, in the experience of probably thousands of people, highly survivable.

You'll adapt to it, you will not end dead.

The species as a whole will probably get better at handling hotter climate with "bare hands" if you wait a little - 10-20 years - most probably the genetic baseline for this adaptation is already in place, maybe epigenetics will trigger it fairly fast for those who have not lived in hot places.


So, where I live, summers are really hot, and we - a couple of million of people here - are really adapted.

i.e. we are here well into the boreal winter, and we had a hefy 35° at midday, today.

Well, then running 10-15 km. in 60 min. at 45-48° (humidity at 80-90%), is quite possible, and yeah, you end up not having any health issues.

Let's take a look how it actually felt to me - several times - to run at 48° and 90% of humidity - actual data from my cellphone - for those who have not tried it.

First you go out to the street, yeah, it's not the Sahara, it is just your neighborhood. You hit the street and the heat hits you, heavily, it is like getting yourself into a body of water, but it is hot air, really hot air. Then magic happens, you get entirely covered by sweat, full-body, your legs (hopefully you're in shorts), arms, everything under clothes is fastly covered in sweat. The first minutes you just take a very slow pace, almost walking fast through the heat, your heart starts to rapidly fire if you try to go faster than this, so you take it slowly, maybe a couple of hundred of meters, at some point the sweat (probably? could be the skin), start to make its magic: you stop feeling the intense heat and start to feel how the sweats cools itself while you are moving through the air. Yep, heavy sweat over your body doesn't heat itself and the air current actually cools it off a bit (probably, I'm not measuring it by any means, just running like many run at 48-50° here).

That's a shield against atmospheric heat, and your body begins to work better, your heart rate slows down A LOT, you keep moving, breathing a bit slower every meter, till you get to an equilibrium, and then you start to actually run.

This happens in maybe the initial 500 to 800 meters of the several km. you're naturally able to run. Then you usually run the 30-40% of what you are usually capable in sub-48°

At some point you'll need to restart the process, you'll feel exactly when, because the sweat over your body begins to be too hot, and your heart rate start to climb wildly. Many runners just slow down to a fast walk till the heart cools it off, or just go to full stop and call it a day or they take cool water and restart the race after that.

I think these studies should be done in places where actual high temperatures have existed for hundreds of years, and there you'll know how able to handle it are real humans who have experience intense heat first hand their entire life.

i.e those that do not consider 40-50° as "heat wave", but just regular summer temperatures.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: