Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

That's a train every 3 minutes.

What country has this? Definitely not USA, Canada, Mexico, Australia, Spain, France, Italy, or Portugal.

EDIT: My mistake, thank you folks! Your experience traveling abroad is different than mine. For a proper train in especially Spain or Italy during off-peak hours, there were often only one per day for many routes.

Caltrain and BART are both still utter disgraces.



Popular intracity buslines in bigger Dutch cities drove every 5-10 mins at peak times pre-COVID. It's really not that high of a standard.


During peak hours, NYC has subways running every 2-5 minutes. It’s usually a 5-10 minute wait during the day otherwise (and it’s about a 20 minute wait off-hours).


From some recent HN discussions, a 2 minute headway for tracked transit seems to be the minimum based on both safe stopping distances and dwell time.

BART achieved 4 minute headways through the San Francisco subway portion. That also effectively limits headways on branch lines (absent additional trackage through SF) as when multiple 15m headway lines are combined the net headway is reduced.

For longer-haul commute service, 5--10 m headways aren't unreasonable, and a dedicated East-bayshore or Peninsula bayshore BART line might be able to accomplish this, with either a transfer or dedicated trackage in SF itself.

(Muni Metro runs on what was intended to be additional BART trackage.)

See:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31774765

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31834413


> What country has this? Definitely not [...] France

Many metro lines in Paris run at less than 3 minute intervals during peak times (when there aren't any "incidents"). Even the aging line 6 has around 3 minute intervals during rush hour.

I'm not very familiar with the Bay Area, so I don't know how these would compare to the line described by OP distance-wise. Longer distance trains in Paris (RER and other suburban lines) don't run at 3 minute intervals either.


The skytrain in Vancouver, Canada has 3 minute frequency at peak.


The o-train in Ottawa and the greens and orange lines in Montreal too.


Hong Kong and Singapore do. It's quite nice, really.


The new Sydney Metro has trains every 4 minutes in some areas. Can’t really remember ever waiting long for a train in Barcelona when I lived there.


Subways in London, Tokyo and Moscow. Probably not on all lines though and maybe not at all times.


the Victoria line in London has 36 trains per hour

or a train every 1 minute 40 seconds

(2 track railway, all station stops)


I can catch a tram every 4 minutes during peak times a block from my apt in NL. I haven't had to drive in years.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: