Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It is my understanding that the American country music industry employs much more specialization of labor (e.g. performers / lyricists / composers are all different people) than other American genres, so I generally expect the quality to be higher.

My sister and I both love country music. My dad is very vocal about how much he hates it, but his reasons have nothing to do with the quality of the music - they are purely cultural. Country music is part of the South, and like any member of respectable Californian society he believes that the South is evil. This does not leave room to enjoy Southern music.

But I suspect that overseas they are more likely to view country music through the same lens as "America", having no specific concept of "despicable Southerners".



>But I suspect that overseas they are more likely to view country music through the same lens as "America", having no specific concept of "despicable Southerners".

I think you're going to find that the rest of the world is going to have much more commonality in social cultural viewpoints of the American South than with California.


But that doesn't matter if they can't tell the difference between California and the South in the first place.

Another commenter in this thread mentions the popularity of country music in France, which would appear to be more on the California end of things.


Depends on what part of France. I'm sure French farmers will find quite a bit in common with American farmers. I'd be surprised if country music is popular among Parisians.


A lot of country music came from California, although from the parts of it (like Bakersfield) that were more Southern then, not very popular with the rest of the state now, and have meth and gun violence problems.


The South is as much a region as a set of attitudes.

There are certainly rural parts of California which are Southern in that sense, just like Ohio is very Southern in that sense.

You will find proud Southerners less than 100 miles from Chicago in fact. That includes (light, but perceptible) southern accents.


Not just that, but someone hugely popular like George Strait will record albums with session players and then tour with his regular band.

I’m sure that happens with pop music as well, but it’s not something that people are open about.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: