Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I rewatch SG-1 in its entirety every few years. Season 1 is by far the weakest thing until the last episode when we're told the Earth has a couple of... shuttles to defend itself against the aliens. From there, it's just pure fun for another 9 seasons.

Is it "the best sci-fi" out there? I can't say because Battlestar Galactica had its moments, Voyager had seasons 4-7, and the current (but last) Expanse season is absolutely incredible in every respect.

But SG-1 will always be an immutable top 3 entry for me. It's so much even my wife watched a few seasons with me back in the day. I love to see her laugh



>I can't say because Battlestar Galactica had its moments

Rewatching BSG recently and seeing the prisoner-abuse scenes on the Pegasus (no less with Cain as a woman in charge, stood particularly out to me this time) or the commentary on military occupation from the perspective of the insurgents during the height of the Iraq war on Syfy of all places really cemented why the show stuck with me.


BSG is my all time favorite, the only downside is that you cannot repeat the true first watch experience, the cliffhangers are not as powerful anymore.

SG-1 on the other hand is just as great on the 5th rewatch, but as others have mentioned, it doesn’t want itself to be taken too seriously.


SG-1 for me is like a great slice of pizza. Not fine dining, but a comfort food that hits the spot in a way that makes me come back more frequently.


BSG was less of a sci-fi and more of a drama that happened to take place in space


Haha, there are dozens of us. Atlantis was good too, too bad for SGU ...




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: