Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Are you suggesting the average American got fat off environmentally friendly low-carbon-impact food products? Because I suspect they got fat off Oreos and Coca-Cola.


Those are vegan products; I'd guess they have relatively low environmental impact aside from their plastic packaging.


Those have a lower carbon impact than meat.


[flagged]


> I'm suggesting exactly what I said. Would you like me to repeat it?

You're being aggressive and condescending for no reason. To quote you, "I thought HN was better than this."

> When beef has the 30x the environmental impact of plant based food per calorie, it would be hard to make the statement that fat people are automatically to blame for climate change.

This isn't what anybody suggested. As obesity rises, people eat more, creating the food to sustain those people causes a greater environmental impact. If more people drive cars, we need more gas, right?

> The whole argument is just completely ignorant on its face.

You're angry for no reason.

> Dispute what I said instead of making glib replies.

Done.

> Do you think every calorie has the same environmental impact? No? Because OF COURSE NOT. So what are you even disagreeing with?

More net calories is more net carbon. Basic math, friend.


[flagged]


> Did you know it is socially awkward to respond to someone who isn't talking to you?

No, that's how online message boards work.


> An overweight vegetarian has lower environmental impact that an average weight meat eater.

Gallup has the US at 5% vegetarian. Math doesn't add up.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: