Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You're pro having 30 people breathing in a small room with bad airflow for multiple hours when there's a pandemic?

If you don't know how it's transmitted, then try various things and see if they help. We tried lockdown, and it worked. So we kept doing it, if it didn't change the situation we would have tried other things instead.



Yup. I think that fucking up the education of children, especially those from low socio-economic status backgrounds, is worse than the deaths not doing it causes.

It is not that lockdown is bad or wrong. It is that I do not agree with all the things which were hit. I acknowledge there is a price to keeping education open but I believe it would have been worthwhile.

Perhaps you missed my point? Governing is about more than keeping the most people alive.


> Perhaps you missed my point? Governing is about more than keeping the most people alive.

Actually I believe that’s table stakes for good governance. Trading known deaths for possible impact to development of children isn’t even in the realm of equal, which is why most places didn’t do it.


But we’ll trade thousands of lives to secure some nice minerals in Afghanistan. Cmon.


And, early on it was not sure how Covid would affect children. Their lives and health are still more important than their education. Better be conservative in hazardous circumstances. Better safe than sorry


How has their development been impacted? I mean apart from the ones who died.


Why is their education fucked up?

What about the children who infected their parents and now they're orphans?


There is very little proof that lockdowns worked. We had no clue if they worked going in and we still can’t prove they worked, let alone well enough to justify their immense societal costs.


I mean, I made a chart, seems pretty obvious https://imgur.com/a/mI8OdpW


Do we have proof that the "societal costs" were immense, compared to what they could have been if more people died?


We tried lockdown, and it worked. So we kept doing it

No, we tried lockdowns, they did not work well, then extended them, then again. In my country some school children did not go to school for a whole year because people with anxiety disorder thought opening schools would kill children, parents and grand parents.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: