Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Banks also inflate the money supply using fractional reserve banking, effectively diminishing the value of every other dollar in active currency.

If you think that is honest behavior, then bury all your money for 10 years and then try to spend it. Suprise! You've been robbed.

If I'm not mistaken, there is an eventual limit on the amount of bitcoins that can ever be created.



That's not entirely a negative... We're better off that people are incentivized to not bury all their money. Deflationary spirals are no fun.


I agree that circulation of currency/commodities is necessary for a healthy economy. I don't agree that we're better off having value stolen from our currency by inflating it for the sake of "incentive".

How many joe sixpacks actually spend their money as quickly as possible because they're afraid of inflation? Hopefully it never comes to that.

> Deflationary spirals are no fun. $5/gallon of gas and $7/gallon of orange juice are no fun either.


Banks inflate the money without creating (printing) it physically. I guess a bank taking deposits and giving loans in bitcoins would do just the same.


>If you think that is honest behavior, then bury all your money for 10 years and then try to spend it. Suprise! You've been robbed.

That does induce people to spend,invest or save(savings in banks are loaned out to others by the banks) which drives the economy.

The problem with bitcoin right now is that it's being thought of an investment to hold on to, instead of a currency that must be exchanged for goods.

Imagine if the dollar was appreciating in value big time every week and month. People would stop spending and just hog them. The economy as we know if might collapse and lead to a full blown depression.


> instead of a currency that must be exchanged for goods.

My prediction is the bitcoin market will correct itself, as markets without interference do. Bitcoins are intrinsically worthless, like the USD, unless it can be exchange for goods/services.

> Imagine if the dollar was appreciating in value big time every week and month.

As long as a central banking authority (Federal Reserve) can legally make dollars from thin air, this will never happen.


The problem is that people are using BitCoin as a 'Get Rich Quick' scheme instead of a currency. While this does drive adoption, some lives may be destroyed on the way because of market manipulation by malicious parties. How many legitimate transactions are happening compared to transactions with an intent to hoard BitCoins for future gains?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: