Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Is it unusual to be able to play back music in one’s head and hear it almost exactly the same as hearing it aloud?

When I imagine music in my mind, the sonic qualities all seem the same as what I heard or hear, though sometimes I’ll mentally edit the arrangement intentionally or unintentionally.

I’ve also noticed that when I use my voice to sing melodies for compositional purposes, imagining the melody and singing are basically the same thing or have the same end result. On the other hand, using synthesizers and messing with patches usually leads to things I wouldn’t have always imagined in my head.

I’ve never asked anyone about any of this before, so I never realized others might not experience the same things. Sometimes I wish I could switch subjective experience for a day with another person to get real perspective.



I have to think it's a common skill. I listen to music in my head all the time, and I'm barely a hobbyist guitarist. If I can do it with enough clarity and precision to enjoy the experience, I'd think pretty much anyone could.


Same here exactly. I agree, it’s really fun to experiment with patches.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: