Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> The West has a huge military and space program. So does China

I don’t think this is true. China’s military is quite weak compared to the US (dollar amount, global reach, navy, nuclear) and it’s not able to project power globally. Even as far as the Middle East would be a problem as they don’t have bases or carrier groups.

This is actually kind of an advantage as they can funnel money into more productive purposes, but I think it means they won’t be the sort of unipolar force that the US was.

I think the 21st century will be multi-polar and if I had to bet on a single country, I would bet Nigeria or maybe even somewhere like DRC or Brazil. A truly digital world will be best for countries in Africa who have so much untapped raw power and resources.



It's not just untrue is laughably untrue. I'm not a big fan of US military power, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't be realistic about it. The US military really is the last global superpower. Pretty much all of the global sea lanes rely on the US navy for stability.


By some measures China's navy is larger than the US's [0]:

>In a report published this month, the Pentagon acknowledged a grim milestone: China’s navy, having churned out warships like sausages, has become the world’s largest.

I'm not aware of many signs that this trend will decrease.

[0] https://www.economist.com/united-states/2020/09/26/china-now...


The Pentagon's incentivized to exaggerate any threat though, because it justifies more funding to themselves.

I'd say that the real threat, as far as navies go, is what if our carrier-heavy paradigm is obsolete and cheaper missile cruisers are more effective.


China is, at best, a Pacific power, but really they're just regional. China cannot project sea lane power past Japan at this point. The dirty secret of China's economy is that they're incredibly dependent on the American military for stable trade relations.


150 years ago, the same was said of the US by the then global hegemon, the British Empire.

I'm not saying you're wrong, but it's important to note that these things can change.

The Pax Americana is a real thing, even if it's held up more by Hollywood than gunboats right now.


Largest and strongest are not the same thing.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: