Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

To be honest, at this point I wish email would just die and get replaced with an actual modern protocol. It's a nightmare. Everything about it sucks.


Please don't. Anything modern would another lock-in. I can read decade old emails, switched multiple providers. Messages in those 'new protocols' are long unaccessible and protocols themselves are dead.


At this point at least pay for delivery would give you some path to actually get to users.


Spammers would pay too, maybe even outbid the genuine users. They already invest a lot into getting past filters.


Such as? How would it work?


Not having trivially forged headers would be a start.


Isn’t this basically what SPF, DKIM and SMTP over TLS get you? Sure you can try to forge messages but they should bounce immediately and not even reach the recipients inbox.


I’m not an expert... but From what I can tell no one trusts anyone’s email anymore and even as we added these new security things.. we didn’t start trusting any more than we did before... Consequences being that even with the extra security, trying to run your own mail server and get email recipients to receive the mail you send is like being some kind of extremely polite red team, on the offensive in the worlds longest least organised capture the flag.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: