Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

What about non-violent protests?

Seems like they often exist to expose systemic violence that is underappreciated, undocumented, forgotten, etc. That is, show what the violent are really willing to do to get them to alienate themselves.



That’s great for showing people that the violent people are bad guys, but the violent ones aren’t going to get any less violent by being exposed.

It’s the threat of reprisal from the entire population that does that.


It's partly that, but it also serves to fracture and de-motivate the "violent people". A ruler cannot necessarily count on blind obedience from the military and the police if they start ordering them to attack their fellow citizens.

While some regimes get overthrown by mass uprisings, many more lose power because they either lose support from the security state or create an insurrection inside of it. Of course the lines here are often fuzzy.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: