Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Airplane mode means no radio. Handsets will not transmit anything, and thus obviously will not attempt to connect to a network, in airplane mode.

The article is largely fear mongering, though. The way the system is designed means that the location of every connected device is known at least at cell level. If that wasn't the case you could not be called!

Edit: by law they have have to keep location data, though I'm not sure to what extent.

The author of this article does not seem to know the topic but makes sweeping, borderline conspiratist, claims...



Oddly it turns out that these days airplane mode doesn mean turn off all RF transmissions. e.g. it can mean "configure for use in an aircraft under fcc jurisdiction" which means turn off cell radio but keep Wifi on.

Source: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT204234


That would be great.

Apparently Apple phones will silently phone home an SMS as an iMessage heartbeat when you turned off data.

I bought a SIM card in France, loaded 10 EUR for a 9,95 plan. But my balance declined to 9,85 despite having data turned off and not making any calls/SMSs.

There was no record in Messages, but my provider showed me sending a text.

Ugh. Another 5 EUR added just to buy the 9,95 plan.


> Apparently Apple phones will silently phone home an SMS as an iMessage heartbeat

I recently traveled abroad and bought a local SIM card, and when I first activated it I got a dialog asking if I approved of it sending the iMessage activation SMS. It wasn't silent.

I don't know how new this behavior is


Seems new. I still dunno why Apple made it such a secret.

Drove me bonkers when my carrier claimed I sent an SMS but my phone showed I had not.

Edit: others reported that there’s a message that said “Your Carrier May charge for SMS messages used to activate iMessage” that would still send even if you hit “Cancel”.

Seems like a lot of providers don’t charge for this SMS, but for those that do, it can be a costly int’l SMS.


There's nothing odd about that, right? It's called "airplane mode".


Yes, but technically there's no reason to keep knowing that once you've left that cell.


Technically, no, by law, yes [1]

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_retention




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: