Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Some people are questioning:

“Facebook is the most powerful private entity on the earth right now, far more powerful than most nation states”

Op did not clarify his reasoning. Though I have thought about this and here are mine.

If strip down a “nation state” to its bare essence, it is an idea. Lines drawn on a map, and symbols(flags, anthems etc). Add in the government directing education, and we end up with masses that can be influenced to behave in specific ways. i.e socialisation and sense of identity.

Now, we know that government plays a significant part in the country and in the world.

Now let’s consider FB. FB has by far the largest network of people that are connected in one massive network. I suspect Information (memes) could spread much faster on Fb, Whatsapp and insta than they could prior to these. Even email was never as fast. Since FB has control of the network without over sight on the algorithms and filtering, they wield significant power to shape global conversations. Shaping global conversations fundamentally can lead to over throwing of leaders with out ever a bullet being shot, it could lead to genocide, nationalism etc etc.

It’s no surprise that the EU is on high alert.

Edit: I think this requires more exploring. This is fundamentally a war against a new form of influence & control of masses of people.

See previous wars: religion vs state, state vs monarchy etc etc.

Has anyone considered this perspective before? Would appreciate any links



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: