Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

If you ever fill 3 lanes than you need to seriously invest in public transport. More than 3 lanes is never a sane idea. 9 lanes is an absolute atrocity.


> If you ever fill 3 lanes than you need to seriously invest in public transport.

Um, you do realize that the George Washington Bridge is in New York City, one of the largest cities in the world, with an extensive system of public transportation? The idea that if NYC would just invest in some public transport those 9 lanes would go down to 3 is laughable.


I somewhat agree with the parent poster. The city's design should not require 9 lanes. I didn't see 9 lanes roads in Tokyo and it's bigger than NYC.


> I didn't see 9 lanes roads in Tokyo and it's bigger than NYC.

That's because Tokyo and NYC are different cities in different countries, populated by people with very different preferences.

My point was not that NYC's public transportation and highway systems are optimal by the criterion of "optimal" that the poster I responded to appears to be using. My point was that the fact that NYC doesn't look optimal to him is not that NYC has simply failed to consider public transportation as an alternative. It's that, as I said, NYC is populated by people with different preferences from his, and NYC's public transportation and highway systems reflect those preferences.


That's because NYC and most of America is dysfunctional to the point where people think that a 18 lane road is not just necessary but actually a good idea. Not a single place in the US has good public transport. Maybe good to US standards but thats a low bar.


> That's because NYC and most of America is dysfunctional

Not to those of us who live in America. That's the nice thing about having different countries, and different states, cities, etc. within countries: it enables people with widely different definitions of "functional" to all find a place to live, instead of everybody having to conform to somebody's fixed idea of how people should live.


Well I guess if you enjoy spending hours stuck in traffic and having air that slowly kills you.


What makes you think "most of America" (or even most of NYC) experiences this?


The fact that there are nine lanes gives it away.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: