Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Some people have died while using elevators

For some reason I forgot about this in an earlier comment I made about people wanting someone to blame.

But here we have what could be argued as a "simplest version of self-driving vehicle, with no human operator at the controls, and no one to immediately blame when somebody is hurt or killed by the system"...

So the question is - has there been a study done on how people respond to such incidents, when they have no one to blame? At least, in the moment? They can't "yell at the elevator". Eventually, they may yell at the owner of the property or the manufacturer of the elevator, or whatever company last did maintenance (ie - yell -> lawsuit).

But does that stop them from using elevators ever again (I imagine that a percentage do become fearful; I know I read something of that nature regarding people who've been "trapped" for a long period of time in an elevator, especially those who are alone when it happens)?

Also - why do others continue to use elevators, and not take the stairs (this is more a rhetorical question - stairs are not an option in a skyscraper over more than a few stories for most people)?

I'm just interested in why a self-driving car is so different to people, beyond the relative "novelty" of it? Will we completely reject it, because it can't be made 100% perfect? Or will we get used to them in time, even though statistically someone somewhere will die occasionally from an accident in one?

I'm not looking for answers here; it's just something that I ponder when these kinds of discussions come up, as I've had a bit of minor experience in learning about (and how to create) these kinds of systems.



The parallelisms don't end there: elevators used to be much more complicated that they are now. Instead of having one button per floor they had motor controls. They literally had to be "driven" by human operators.

I don't remember if any studies were cited, but the "elevators vs self-driving cars" was studied in the Planet Money podcast: https://www.npr.org/2015/07/31/427990392/remembering-when-dr...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: