Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> I don’t believe in moral relativism.

Good for you? The homeless, penniless child should never steal the loaf of bread when all other, apparent, options are exhausted.

> They don’t get a pass for not knowing better.

They get a pass because it was already decided a long time ago that they were too dangerous for outsiders to be allowed near. They're contained, and by the survey numbers their population is dwindling. In another century the island could well be uninhabited. A small speck of isolated land that no one has any need to go to is easy enough to leave alone.

> Just as their victims didn’t get a pass for not knowing better.

Except their victim (in this case) certainly did know better. They even chased him off multiple times before finally killing him.



> The homeless, penniless child should never steal the loaf of bread when all other, apparent, options are exhausted.

'The law, in its majestic equality, forbids rich and poor alike to sleep under bridges, to beg in the streets, and to steal their bread.' - Anatole France


I don’t see how a single homeless child is comparable. This is more like justifying North Korea’s methods because the poor country is just trying to survive.

The victim should have known they were murderous savages but gave them the benefit of the doubt anyway.


> murderous savages

Racial flamewar is not allowed on HN either. Please don't post this kind of thing again.


How is calling them murderous savages racist? It makes no generalisations of their race. Even if one interperts it as a generalisation of their race, how is it prejudice or discrimination when it is an accurate description (given the previous murders commited by them)? Genuinely curious.


It's an obvious trope of racist discourse. Maybe the most obvious of all time. Therefore it's flamebait, in addition to whatever else it is, and the fire department needs to turn a hose on it.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: