Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

strange. This post was flagged and even showed up dead just a few mins ago. Did the mods restore this ?


Probably the "vouch" feature working. Countdown on it being flagged down again: 1, 2, 3...


And it's flagged again.


Interesting progression. For a while, it was flagged, and still racking up points at the #1 position, but now it's gone far away.

I wish we could actually discuss the issues raised by situations like this, without the pitchfork and flagging brigades coming out. You would think a site focused on technology could discuss IT security, hacking, and the potential influence of technology companies in shaping and directing political opinion. But unfortunately it tends to get shutdown before anything can get started.


Where does the vouch link show up? I don't recall ever seeing one.


You have to click on the comment's timestamp to go to its page. Then (assuming the comment is [dead]) you'll see a 'vouch' link at the top. That's the same place where the 'flag' links for comments appear. If the comment isn't [dead], there's no 'vouch' link, because the reason to vouch for comments is to resurrect them from [dead].


EDIT: I was a bit wrong. Here's a post from dang explaining it.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11843347#11844960

> The system used to say [flagged] only when the story was both heavily flagged and dead (closed to new comments). Now it says [flagged] if the story is heavily flagged, dead or not. Flagged-but-not-dead was the case here. That's why you didn't see a 'vouch' link, btw; there's no need to vouch for posts that aren't dead, since the purpose of vouching is to unkill them.


Right after the '1 hour ago', I think there might be a points restriction on being able to vouch.


It's disgusting how this is flagged. Stop trying to hide facts.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: