Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | wehnsdaefflae's commentslogin

Maybe they want to be tokenizer agnostic? Then they would need to go by character count, right? Despite these inconsistencies, has anyone actually verified their promise? 350 vs. 10.000 tokens would still be very valuable even if they mess up some edge cases


Oh it is not returning full tool schema. You can't cut down that much by serialisation alone.


Well, I can


So humans don't do "genuine reasoning"?


We do do genuine reasoning. It would take a lot of practice for us to learn it but we also use less "electricity" to do it.

The thing about LLMs is there doesn't seem to be a way to teach them genuine reasoning. You can spend a month teaching an LLM brainfuck and it would likely still fail at a novel problem. Whereas if a human studied brainfuck for a month they would probably be quite competent at a novel problem


I would in fact expect any human that's as good at writing code as various state-of-the-art LLMs (if you take the breathless proclamations of their hype bros at face value) to be able to solve the rather simple problems in the benchmark given the relevant esolang spec and some time to figure it out.

It's not as if the models here were asked to write a kernel in Brainfuck; the medium tier of problems here contains such apparently insurmountable tasks as "calculate the nth prime".


No. I’m just an NPC in someone else’s simulation. Wandering the world aimlessly incapable of expressing ideas outside of my training corpus of language. Pathetic.


Not crazy. Same with me. My mom always tells me how much nicer it is talking with me when I'm hungover.


Stating that consciousness is observer dependent while using observers to determine whether sth is conscious tickles need the wrong way


Paywalled


Unavoidably this comment. But is it actually kafkaesque though?


Not sure if sarcasm...


I tried to register. It threw an error. On retry it showed me a couple of user names and addresses of people I've never heard of before. Big red flag for me.


"cute"... what are you criticizing exactly?


I'm not, I still think it's a cute idea.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: