Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | nn3's commentslogin

Exactly. Either everyone is confused, or something is missing from the article.

I was disappointed he didn't debug why amazon kept shutting down his tablet.


There are many examples in anquity. Greek had a flowering in the Bronze age, then a dark age, before classical Greek took over. The Hittites had a major disaster including the destruction of their capital before they recovered in a great way (until their final demise at the end of the Bronze age). Egypt had several dark periods where they recovered from, until they fell prey to Greek and Roman imperialism.


What's also annoying is that sizes of the same clothes change. I have a pair of jeans that I ordered on Amazon in 2020. It happens to fit me great. So recently I decided to order two more of the same. I got exactly the same model with the same size on Amazon, just with different colors. But neither fit very well, they were far wider. The first one had such a horrible fit that I immediately sent it back. The other I can wear, but it's quite different from the other perfectly fitting one. Why are they doing that? It's insane.


How do we know the Cambridge Philosopher is conscious?


I don't feel his overflow miscompilation example is a good one. A 64bit multiplication converted back to 32bit has the same overflow behavior as if the computation was in 32bit (assuming nobody depends on the overflow indication, which is rare). And in high level programming languages you typically can't tell the difference.


St. Petersburg (at least for some time)


Thats the pascal kernel in all its glory. Its just a bare metal hello world

KernelMain(); [public name 'kernelMain']; begin consoleClearDisplay(); consoleSetAttributes(White, Black); consolePutString('Hello world'); end;


chimpanzees, gorillas, orangutans evolved intelligence too. They are smarter than most other critters in the jungle. Just all not as much as the lineage that leads to humans.

It's actually quite difficult to define human intelligence. Every time we think we find something unique by humans eventually some animal turns up that can do it too. It may be all just a question of degree and how it's used.


From what I've heard, language is unambiguously unique to humans, if you consider grammar an integral part of languages. You can teach chimpanzees hand signs, but they could never make the leap to stringing them together under a coherent rule: something like the difference between "Mom give me cookies" vs "I give mom cookies."

(I'm no expert, so take that with a grain of salt.)


Cetacean communication obeys Zipf's law: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11797547/

As does house finches: https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/full/10.1098/rspb.202...

Sperm whale codas exhibit contextual and combinatorial structure: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-024-47221-8

Ants have developed symbolic language: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10093743/

Everywhere we look close enough, we find life doing smart things.


Those are interesting examples. Do you know of a species where ALL of those properties (and more) exist?


Likely all of the ones named, and more. These are just a sampling of papers and not at all exhaustive.


Bee "dance" communication is remarkably sophisticated and precise

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waggle_dance?wprov=sfla1


proto-grammers are fairly common. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alex_(parrot) for example shows that parrots are capable of understanding English word order to some extent.


Don't think so. Whales and dolphins seem to have a fairly sophisticated language with regional dialects and accents.


Unique to modern humans, maybe. But that's only because we outcompeted/killed all of our sibling species that also spoke language. Denisovans likely had language as well.


Are there any other animals that have a system of writing?


No, but humans didn't have writing up until pretty recently either so I don't think that is a great measure of base intellectual capability.


The interesting part is how do you research that.

Starting from what should be considered "writing" to how to identify specific artifacts as abstract words.

Some researchers spend years in the forest studying one animal to isolate one single word they're speaking. Understanding other kind of intelligences is a crazy complex task.


Researchers have taught primates to communicate using sequences of simple symbols. It's sort of like a system of writing but very primitive.


Not even close.

Some great apes can learn to use symbols for communication. Bees can use specific dances to indicate direction and distance.


I dont think any other animal even have language at all (at least not language like we use the word language)


This is actually not correct for Starlink. They did a lot of work to lower their albedo based on astronomer complaints, even though there wasn't any government regulation in this area.

It might apply to some of the emerging Starlink competitors however, especially the Chinese ones and AST.


The albedo reduction they worked on is the exact reason why I wrote this, "...or if they think that a government order is imminent so they come to some voluntary agreement ahead of time."

SpaceX only "voluntarily" did that because the government was likely to put more stringent requirements on them if they ignored the complaints.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: