Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more barbariangrunge's commentslogin

What is recall ai?


It's a system microsoft designed that took regular screenshots of what was happening on the desktop, stored them in a sqlite database, and then allowed people to ask their "AI" questions that would take into account literally everything they user has ever done on their computer.

People pointed out that this would record things like people watching porn, typing in banking credentials, viewing bills, filing taxes, etc etc. The thread of having these sqlite database leaked, combined with the amount of malware and randomware already out there, made a lot of security folks get very very concerned.


I didn't think Recall was about answering questions - there was no LLM component - so much as it was about being able to search your history, based on a combination of SQLite FTS against OCRd text plus CLIP-style embeddings-based semantic search against the content of those images.


> Microsoft says Recall lets you find anything you've seen or done on your PC with a simple search query, and it's powered by state-of-the-art large language models, which can understand various content on your PC, like text, images, and videos. It works in any application, so you can search across your computer.

https://www.wired.com/story/everything-announced-microsoft-s...


Weird. I got the impression they were using embedding models (which I think of as LLM-adjacent) but not actual LLMs. See notes here: https://simonwillison.net/2024/Jun/5/ai-features-in-microsof...


I haven't actually dug into it myself, so it could just be that marketers or journalists got mixed up somewhere.


That’s horrifying



The main content seems to be this:

> if someone “fears” they may become a victim of a hate crime, they can go before a judge, who may summon the preemptively accused for a sort of precrime trial. If the judge finds “reasonable grounds” for the fear, the defendant must enter into “a recognizance.”

> A recognizance is no mere promise to refrain from committing hate crimes. The judge may put the defendant under house arrest or electronic surveillance and order them to abstain from alcohol and drugs. Refusal to “enter the recognizance” for one year results in 12 months in prison.


I used to laugh at right wing media for calling leftist government fascist.

But this is out right scary.


Why? The nazis were socialists. Just look at their party platform. Nationalist, but most definitely socialist.

https://encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/article/nazi-party...

   We demand therefore:
   
   11. The abolition of incomes unearned by work.
   
   The breaking of the slavery of interest
   
   12. In view of the enormous sacrifices of life and property demanded of a nation by any war, personal enrichment from war must be regarded as a crime against the nation. We demand therefore the ruthless confiscation of all war profits.
   
   13. We demand the nationalization of all businesses which have been formed into corporations (trusts).
   
   14. We demand profit-sharing in large industrial enterprises.
   
   15. We demand the extensive development of insurance for old age.
   
   16. We demand the creation and maintenance of a healthy middle class, the immediate communalizing of big department stores, and their lease at a cheap rate to small traders, and that the utmost consideration shall be shown to all small traders in the placing of State and municipal orders.
   
   17. We demand a land reform suitable to our national requirements, the passing of a law for the expropriation of land for communal purposes without compensation; the abolition of ground rent, and the prohibition of all speculation in land.
   
   18. We demand the ruthless prosecution of those whose activities are injurious to the common interest. Common criminals, usurers, profiteers, etc., must be punished with death, whatever their creed or race.


If I didn’t know any better, I’d have assumed that was a Soviet platform. Weird! Thanks for sharing those quotes. You can see how those positions might have been appealing to Germans after wwi, and how the maniac could have used them to manipulate his way to power


TIL Nazis were socialists and North Korea is Democratic republic.


Don't forget the foremost democratic country, the GDR. It's right in their name, man!


Strange that the Nazis purged the KPD/SDP if they were both socialist.


Why? Given how much US socialist groups condemn each other or infight, it doesn't seem Nazis would be unique to purity check competing parties or treat them like traitors.


The ideological differences were more than “Judea’s People’s Front”.


Read Orwell's account of fighting for one of the socialist groups in Spain, and how one of those groups wiped out the others when they had the chance.

There is plenty of historical accounts of socialists killing socialists.


The Spanish civil was between anarchists, fascists and communists.


Given that Orwell took part in the war (took a bullet) and everyday life I think I will trust his account not yours :)


Please don't take word for it. It's easily verifiable historical fact.


Stalin exiled Trotsky. They were both socialist.

Just because people or groups are enemies doesn't mean they disagree on everything.


Goldberg is a polemicist, not a historian, and frankly not all that competent even in his acknowledged line. Do better - by not ignoring the Night of the Long Knives, for a start.


That's an appeal to authority and with that not relevant. What about the night of the long knives means the NDSAP was not ideologically aligned with socialism. Parties which make socialism part of their platform run the gamut from social democrat parties in western Europe to the Khmer Rouge and anything in-between. There's plenty of blood on 'socialist' hands. That does not mean there is blood on all socialist hands. The same goes for nationalism.


> What about the night of the long knives means the NDSAP was not ideologically aligned with socialism

The part where the right-corporatist wing of the party secured its hold on power by executing or imprisoning the leaders of its right-socialist wing.


I think the closest analogy is theocracies punishing blasphemous speech.


No, this would be theocracies punishing the possibility of blasphemous speech.


Yeah, arguably even worst.

Most blasphemy laws were (ostensibly) against public speech. The way these laws are phrased if you say something hurtful in a private chat online you could be charged.


Discoverability sucks, for almost everyone, but especially for new authors. And that was before ai started flooding out “content.”

Even if you get a publisher, great authors sometimes sell only a handful of copies. You find amazing books on goodreads by award winning authors with only 5 reviews. And that’s people who can get their novels manuscript even looked at by an editor. Lots of self published authors end up with 0-1 reviews

How do you stand out in that swamp?


This is why you see these massive advances for known names. The only thing publishers seem to know is that authors who create their own publicity sell copies, and those that dont have an audience dont.


"Step one: hype the human, step two: publish their books" reminds me of being a senior in college and seeing and despairing at job postings saying

"MUST have 5 years experience in [tech that came out 9 months ago]"


The problem is that book publishing hasn't really been disrupted for a very long time. Amazon just switched it to selling online, but think about how much more you can engage with a book that you just read. Somehow no apps or ereaders allow for anything beyond reading the book text.


It is being quietly disrupted, just probably not in the way people want.

Webnovels on sites like royalroad.com monetised via patreon and then published on Kindle Unlimited & Audible offer a different publishing model to that of traditional books and one that works really well for the right genres.

The audience that reads them is reading purely for entertainment, has vastly lower standards and is willing to directly support their favourite authors to the point where the most successful authors who started 5 years or so ago are now millionaires.

But this is mostly an anathema to the traditional publishing industry and for the most part they're pretending it doesn't exist because they literally cannot compete with it in the niches it now dominates.


This is correct. I give $3/month on patreon for 2 chapters a week to this one author. $36/year isn't a lot, but it takes these authors' years to finish these books at this rate, and any author would kill for the amount of amount I sunk into 1 book. Multiply it out, and it becomes a livable wage if you can get enough people to support your patreon. I have a friend I personally know who did this. He's not even a good writer. He just found an underserved niche and made a livable wage $1from somebody at a time. His writing improved and I'd say it's passable, but no one would pay $10 at all once for any book he wrote. Apparently over a year is fine though.


This is the interesting thing about this entire thread. There are a lot of opportunities for authors to make a living, even potentially become wealthy writing but they actually have to write in niches people want to read.

Instead I get the sense that the people writing these "debut novels" are really looking for fame/acceptance within the kind of social circles that value "great intellectual novels".


Yeah, I live in a small town. There is no boycotting Walmart, there is nowhere else to go for many things


Be loud then


Job performance doesn’t really matter in tech. It’s all about interview skills and leetcode


> The user agreement also leaves open the possibility to train AI using user-generated content, saying they can use the content they retrieve to “improve our Services and Software“.


They’re double dipping like a lot of these companies. Pay for the service, and use your human made content as valuable training data

Or with something like Reddit use ads to make money then sell api access to human content


It's interesting that they are so hungry for training data that they would seek access to people's half finished photoshop files.

I'm reminded of what just happened to google: this seems as effective a strategy as training an LLM on reddit shitposts.


For alternatives, I really liked the affinity suite, but they just got acquired.


See also: that episode of the British black mirror


Sounds nice until you put yourself in the employees shoes. All your mistakes become public case studies, you’re cut off from proper mentoring, and you can no longer say anything in private to your boss without the whole team hearing it


bear in mind he is a CEO.. His subordinates are most likely SVPs, so his relation with his subordinates is not the same as employees down at the bottom of the hierarchy with their managers..

so i hardly thing he is discussing personal mistakes in those meetings, he is more likely discussing policies that affect entire departments or even the whole company..

Other then that i believe that any person in any position and at any level, should praise in public and criticize in private, always..

But note that he never said he does not have private meetings with his subordinates when needed, he only said he does not think he should have a scheduled time every week to have this kind of discussions..

and honestly i agree with him.. 90% of what i discuss with my manager in our 1:1s could be discussed in front of the whole team.. the other 10% is not something i need to discuss ever other week it is usually stuff about my personal career that i need to discuss just a few times per year.. so for those when the need arise i just reach out to my manager and discuss with him..

also a managers is not always the best person to be coaching someone.. where i work we have managers and we have mentors and those are separated roles that may be taken by different people..


It’s already stolen in a way from all the users who just wanted to be able to use a forum and had no serious alternatives


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: